MM#364--Election 2024--Common Ground?

Transcript

WEBVTT

00:00:07.612 --> 00:00:20.807
Welcome to the Theory to Action podcast, where we examine the timeless treasures of wisdom from the great books in less time, to help you take action immediately and ultimately to create and lead a flourishing life.

00:00:20.807 --> 00:00:24.850
Now here's your host, david Kaiser.

00:00:26.019 --> 00:00:29.710
Hello, I am David and welcome back to another Mojo Minute.

00:00:29.710 --> 00:01:02.225
We are living in the late 18th century and it describes the peaceful atmosphere of London with the chaos and violence occurring in Paris during the horrific French Revolution.

00:01:02.225 --> 00:01:20.043
And doesn't every society that goes through a cultural and physical revolution, such as the one that happened in the French Revolution and is currently taking place in the United States right now, experience those?

00:01:20.043 --> 00:01:22.990
Don't they all experience those very same sentiments?

00:01:22.990 --> 00:01:26.368
The best of times and the worst of times.

00:01:26.368 --> 00:01:40.371
The best of times we see Elon Musk land a rocket back on a launch pad like a toy would do in the imagination of a 12-year-old boy's hand.

00:01:40.371 --> 00:01:43.323
Just incredible technology.

00:01:43.323 --> 00:01:53.748
The best of times we for me, the incredible accessibility to almost any and every book ever written.

00:01:54.992 --> 00:02:00.444
This is truly the golden age of reading and access to information.

00:02:00.444 --> 00:02:07.537
The best of times are instant communication society.

00:02:07.537 --> 00:02:15.093
We find out from loved ones and friends with almost instantaneous speed the ups and downs in their lives.

00:02:15.093 --> 00:02:25.104
Now, that certainly started with the telephone for almost everyday Americans, but it's only increased with a digital age where text messages are sent by the billions.

00:02:25.104 --> 00:02:31.913
Did you know the world sends about 23 billion with a B?

00:02:31.913 --> 00:02:37.288
23 billion text messages around the world each and every day.

00:02:37.288 --> 00:02:39.272
Crazy right.

00:02:39.272 --> 00:02:44.566
Just to give you an idea of how good are the times in which we live.

00:02:44.566 --> 00:03:13.307
Just to give you an idea of how good are the times in which we live, in 1929, just a little under 100 years ago, an estimated 200 million telegrams were sent during the peak year of 1929 for the telegraph.

00:03:13.328 --> 00:03:35.161
And in 1859, when Dickens was putting the final touches on the tale of two cities, the transatlantic telegraph cable had get the news out to a rapidly as possible and eager and anxious nation and, for that matter, the world over.

00:03:35.161 --> 00:03:50.227
Now, just a decade before that, the Associated Press was founded in 1846, partly to help fund those same telegraph wires and to give access to them and to share the cost and covering the news from the then Mexican-American war just beginning to take place.

00:03:50.227 --> 00:04:20.214
Now, that is not the direction of our podcast today, and our direction is that if we picked up the tale of two cities in 1859 and we read those words it's the best of times and the worst of times Could we foresee the political and cultural hurricane that was coming in 1860 with the election of Abraham Lincoln and all of those events that happened in the aftermath as a result.

00:04:20.214 --> 00:04:28.500
And so some of you might be thinking well, that's great, but this is certainly the worst of times.

00:04:28.500 --> 00:04:36.153
We've never had a political party impeach a sitting president two times in one four-year term.

00:04:36.153 --> 00:04:38.343
And was it justified?

00:04:38.343 --> 00:04:40.728
Overwhelmingly it was not justified.

00:04:40.728 --> 00:04:54.153
It's the worst of times, david, because this up-and coming election looks to be very tight and close, with only increases in causes, with more anxiety and trepidation on the country.

00:04:56.100 --> 00:05:23.853
And if our constitutional safeguard of the electoral college helping the small states from getting demolished from the big states that was put in place in the Constitutional Convention for the very reason of having some semblance of fairness and equality If that's put in jeopardy, then does the American Republic exist much more?

00:05:23.853 --> 00:05:37.733
After that, perhaps we should do an episode on why the Electoral College matters in our American Republic and why we are not mob role only by a majority.

00:05:37.733 --> 00:05:44.014
We are not direct vote of the Athenian democracy of 500 BCE.

00:05:44.014 --> 00:05:51.269
And that was the beauty and the wisdom of the founding fathers that we were not, that we were a republic.

00:05:51.269 --> 00:06:12.291
But does repeated elections, where the electoral college is the determining factor for winning elections, cause the system to be weakened each and every time it happens, most especially if the end folks are not learning or being taught how good the American system of government actually is.

00:06:12.291 --> 00:06:20.129
Most young kids can't articulate the reasons for it or, for that matter, the greatness of America.

00:06:20.129 --> 00:06:24.471
They only know the reasons to hate our country.

00:06:26.021 --> 00:06:27.322
The worst of times could be.

00:06:27.322 --> 00:06:41.036
We've never had a presidential candidate been put through five criminal and civil suits with the sole intention to bankrupt him, to incarcerate him and to not allow him to run for the president.

00:06:41.036 --> 00:06:45.545
It's what we call lawfare.

00:06:45.545 --> 00:06:55.069
Now these days We've even created a new word lawfare for that very thing Not allow him to even run.

00:06:55.069 --> 00:07:03.625
Now, you'll remember that these trials didn't come about until Trump actually said he was running for president again.

00:07:03.625 --> 00:07:05.447
Then the lawsuits were filed.

00:07:05.447 --> 00:07:28.509
Then the Biden Justice Department began to make some dangerous and crazy moves, including, for that matter, the number three person at the Federal Department of Justice moving, demoting himself to the New York State to head up that investigation under Attorney Bragg, after Bragg himself dismissed the case, saying there was not enough evidence.

00:07:30.961 --> 00:07:34.689
Worst of times Now they could say the worst of times could be.

00:07:34.689 --> 00:07:41.031
We've never had a presidential candidate who was targeted for assassination on two different occasions.

00:07:41.031 --> 00:08:00.387
Yes, and the fallout of those attempts appears to be grossed incompetence, to the point of sheer malice on the part of a Secret Service who, some three months later, still still has not given the American people a full accounting.

00:08:00.387 --> 00:08:08.797
Even both sides of the political spectrum now would agree there's never been such a collapse from a federal agency.

00:08:08.797 --> 00:08:24.978
The secret service, who takes an oath to protect those very candidates, no matter their party, under its jurisdiction, appears and smells and looks like to be rotten at its core, with hyper partisanship.

00:08:26.882 --> 00:08:31.449
And all of this is to say, are we at an election of no return if one side wins?

00:08:31.449 --> 00:09:14.130
Are we at an election of no return if a Democratic Party who has been radicalized since the beginning of the 21st century and who was given wide latitude under the Obama administration, and who was given wide latitude under the Obama administration If the Democrats win the presidency under Kamala Harris, I think almost by everyone's measure, would certainly qualify to be the least intelligent US president candidate in US history and beyond, question, the most radical US candidate, only to be rivaled by Woodrow Wilson and probably that sociopath, andrew Jackson.

00:09:14.130 --> 00:09:18.342
Would that be the worst of times?

00:09:18.342 --> 00:09:19.966
Perhaps, just perhaps.

00:09:19.966 --> 00:09:26.299
But let me share with you a more negative, implausible view.

00:09:26.299 --> 00:09:27.842
But let me share with you a more negative, implausible view.

00:09:27.842 --> 00:09:32.229
There's an old adage that says it can always get worse.

00:09:32.229 --> 00:09:53.744
And for us conservatives, and the traditional-minded folks who always foresaw that shining city on a hill that Reagan wonderfully word-pictured, for us, what can always get worse is when we lose our republic and that delicate of a gem of federalism.

00:09:53.744 --> 00:09:57.429
That could be the worst of times.

00:09:58.576 --> 00:10:02.407
Now, what do I mean by losing our federalism, the American system of federalism?

00:10:02.407 --> 00:10:13.280
Well, that refers to that distinct and separate division of sharing power between the national and state governments.

00:10:13.280 --> 00:10:27.125
American federalism establishes a system of dual sovereignty where both the federal government and the state governments have their own spheres of authority and there's a certain level of autonomy for each.

00:10:27.125 --> 00:10:33.111
That means that the same territory is controlled by two levels of government.

00:10:33.111 --> 00:10:40.397
There's a division of powers, so to speak, and the Constitution outlines these specific powers for each level of government.

00:10:40.397 --> 00:10:42.546
There's enumerated powers.

00:10:42.546 --> 00:10:52.908
Those are generally the powers explicitly granted to the federal government by the Constitution, such as the power to declare war, regulate interstate commerce and coin money.

00:10:52.908 --> 00:10:55.519
There's the reserve powers.

00:10:55.519 --> 00:11:03.078
The Tenth Amendment reserves powers to the states that are not delegated to the federal government.

00:11:03.078 --> 00:11:15.107
These include creating school systems and overseeing state courts and managing local government, even running state and federal elections.

00:11:15.107 --> 00:11:18.543
And then there's concurrent powers.

00:11:18.543 --> 00:11:25.504
These are the powers shared by both the federal and state governments, such as the power to tax and create lower courts.

00:11:25.504 --> 00:11:41.326
Now the Constitution has a supremacy clause that establishes that federal law is the supreme law of the land, and when federal and state laws conflict, federal law generally supersedes state law.

00:11:42.716 --> 00:11:46.265
But that of American federalism has evolved over time.

00:11:46.265 --> 00:11:50.955
But that of American federalism has evolved over time.

00:11:50.955 --> 00:12:01.534
Initially, the federal government and state governments operated in separate spheres of influence with very minimal overlap.

00:12:01.534 --> 00:12:09.804
Since the 1930s, there's been a shift towards more cooperation between the federal and state governments to address common problems.

00:12:09.804 --> 00:12:13.072
This has led to an expansion of federal government involvement in areas traditionally managed only by the states.

00:12:13.072 --> 00:12:19.548
Now the federal government is almost involved in every facet of American lives.

00:12:19.548 --> 00:12:30.746
Now federalism serves as a check on government power by creating two sovereign powers the national government and state governments, thereby restraining the influence of both.

00:12:30.746 --> 00:12:49.296
So, in summary, american federalism creates a complex system of shared governance and that balances national unity with state autonomy, allowing for both centralized authority and local control in different areas of governance.

00:12:49.296 --> 00:13:02.364
And the beauty of all this, from our founding father's point of view, is they took all power and diluted it, essentially spread it out.

00:13:02.364 --> 00:13:08.991
So there was not a whole bucket of power to be corrupted in one area.

00:13:08.991 --> 00:13:13.900
That's the beauty of our national constitution.

00:13:15.102 --> 00:13:24.895
Now, the prime example of all this that plays out before our very eyes on a daily basis is in the states of California, on one side, and Texas and Florida on the other side.

00:13:24.895 --> 00:13:38.188
For the radical left, they would say that California is going just fine no issues there and for conservatives like myself, we would say that Florida and Texas are just fine.

00:13:38.188 --> 00:13:52.210
But in keeping and getting to the heart of the truth, I wanted to challenge my own assumptions and see if there was a better way or a way to get closer to the truth to help out all Americans.

00:13:52.210 --> 00:14:05.892
In a sense, I wanted to check my own blind spots on the conservative side, see our way through a different sort of lens and perhaps see our way through these difficult times.

00:14:05.892 --> 00:14:13.157
And perhaps see our way through these difficult times, which brings us to our book of the day, the Stakes America at the Point of no Return by Michael Anton.

00:14:13.157 --> 00:14:27.764
It's a political analysis and commentary on the current state of American politics and society, and initially it was written for the 2020 presidential campaign, but I still think it's a great analysis for us today.

00:14:27.784 --> 00:14:30.352
Okay, let's go to the book and see what I mean.

00:14:30.352 --> 00:14:37.485
And now here we are, in so many ways more divided than we were in 1860.

00:14:37.485 --> 00:14:41.956
In so many ways not even a we anymore.

00:14:41.956 --> 00:14:48.798
Restoring American unity in this climate sounds almost comically impossible.

00:14:48.798 --> 00:14:58.315
How to restore unity after five decades and counting of a cold civil war, the rancor of which only seems to intensify month to month?

00:14:58.315 --> 00:15:02.274
I have some ideas which I will get to.

00:15:02.333 --> 00:15:05.773
But first let's understand what is meant by unity.

00:15:05.773 --> 00:15:13.831
It does not mean a unanimous vote in the electoral college, such as George Washington won twice.

00:15:13.831 --> 00:15:21.457
It doesn't mean a return to a bipartisan consensus of World War II and the first decades of the Cold War era.

00:15:21.457 --> 00:15:31.830
It doesn't even mean anything like 1972 or 1984, 49 state landslides which can almost certainly never be repeated.

00:15:31.830 --> 00:15:44.788
Unity in the American political context, really for any republic and one must say for republicanism simply means a shared set of basic goals and assumptions.

00:15:44.788 --> 00:15:50.067
It doesn't mean everyone has to agree on everything, or even like everyone else.

00:15:50.067 --> 00:15:58.961
Indeed, a unified republic may nonetheless be quite divided in certain respects.

00:15:58.961 --> 00:16:08.836
Historically, the most common division in any republic has been economic, with religion and culture providing the underlying bedrock of unity.

00:16:08.836 --> 00:16:17.168
Divisions between patricians and plebeians, oversharing spoils and offices, continually racked Republican Rome.

00:16:17.168 --> 00:16:32.998
But the city also remained fundamentally unified as Rome, with both classes speaking the same language, believing in the same gods, adhering to the same morality and committed to Roman greatness and glory.

00:16:32.998 --> 00:16:37.763
To the same morality and committed to Roman greatness and glory.

00:16:37.763 --> 00:16:51.258
And I love the fact that Michael connects our issues to 1860 and to this now cold civil war which we've been going through, and to the Roman Republic which, well, frankly, why it lasted so long.

00:16:51.258 --> 00:16:54.812
But here's our nugget of wisdom for today.

00:16:55.254 --> 00:16:56.135
Let's go back to the book.

00:16:56.135 --> 00:17:07.738
To say the least, there does not appear to be any shared interest or bond of unity underneath contemporary America's bitter red-blue divide.

00:17:07.738 --> 00:17:22.500
One side loves America, the other hates it or can tolerate it only for what it might someday become were the left's entire program to be enacted without exception.

00:17:22.500 --> 00:17:39.795
In a religious sense, the other invented the god of wokeness which it worships with a diocesan abandon.

00:17:39.795 --> 00:17:46.191
One side speaks only English, the other boasts of literally hundreds of languages now heard in America's blue precincts.

00:17:46.191 --> 00:17:56.238
One side insists that the ultimate moral imperative is to punish the other, which in turn believes that morality requires fairness and equal justice under the law.

00:17:57.965 --> 00:18:03.758
What would partisans of either side cite as something that they share in common with the other?

00:18:03.758 --> 00:18:12.817
The land itself, maybe, but they each go to great lengths not to live anywhere near one another.

00:18:12.817 --> 00:18:15.432
The economy, maybe.

00:18:15.432 --> 00:18:19.915
It's been re-engineered to benefit one side at the expense of the other.

00:18:19.915 --> 00:18:30.256
As for the culture, that reliable unifying bond throughout most of history, to ask is to laugh and cry at the same time.

00:18:30.256 --> 00:18:42.256
The mere shred of cultural unity would seem so far out of reach as to be scarcely worth trying to attain, at least for the foreseeable future.

00:18:42.256 --> 00:18:57.009
I don't believe the country can continue indefinitely without any semblance of a common culture, but focusing right now on the near and medium term impossibility would be folly.

00:18:58.653 --> 00:19:01.057
Which leaves us with economics.

00:19:01.057 --> 00:19:14.919
Economics is the number one issue in this election because Joe Biden and Kamala Harris horrifically laid out inflationary policies and then executed on them.

00:19:14.919 --> 00:19:25.376
Now I have spoken of my love for supply-side economics because I believe, all along with Michael, that that can be and should be a unifying message.

00:19:25.376 --> 00:19:33.151
But the current GOP can't articulate any such thing and people feel Trump gets it.

00:19:33.151 --> 00:19:34.736
But we'll see what happens.

00:19:34.736 --> 00:19:55.736
A week from today, we will look at the greatest Republican President, abraham Lincoln, and see what was his economic vision for the country before the Civil War and before that dreadful war occupied most pretty much all of his time, all of his mind and all of his emotions.

00:19:55.736 --> 00:20:01.936
And we're going to do that after everything settles down, after this election.

00:20:01.936 --> 00:20:07.891
So we're going to have some good Mojo Minutes coming up next week.

00:20:08.191 --> 00:20:23.450
Today's Mojo Minute as we reflect upon how we could have a California, share a culture, share a country with a Texas or a Florida when they seem so far apart.

00:20:23.450 --> 00:20:29.299
Perhaps economics would be our solution.

00:20:29.299 --> 00:20:35.226
Let's get everybody making money again, and then perhaps we can bridge our differences.

00:20:35.226 --> 00:20:48.009
So in today's Mojo Minute, let us pray for a fair and free election, one with complete integrity, no shenanigans from the other side.

00:20:49.451 --> 00:20:51.953
First and foremost, we have to believe in our elections.

00:20:51.953 --> 00:20:55.077
They are well.

00:20:55.077 --> 00:21:01.915
We have to believe that they are the truthful answers to our nation's collective voting as a country.

00:21:01.915 --> 00:21:11.536
It's the bedrock, it's the foundation of our electoral process, as our founding documents remind us of this.

00:21:11.536 --> 00:21:16.776
In fact, that's why it's so important to study our founding documents in detail.

00:21:16.776 --> 00:21:22.478
It's our so-called political religion, as Lincoln so coined the term.

00:21:22.478 --> 00:21:37.536
The idea prominently appears in the United States Declaration of Independence in 1776, stating that governments derive their just powers from the consent of the governed.

00:21:37.536 --> 00:21:49.797
That idea comes to us from Thomas Hobbes and John Locke and Jean-Jacques Rousseau, because they helped us to develop a will of the people.

00:21:49.797 --> 00:21:56.028
You would do well to study these ideas to understand why our republic is so exceptional.

00:21:56.028 --> 00:22:08.136
But for now, we have to pray for a free and fair election, one with complete integrity, no shenanigans from either side.

00:22:08.136 --> 00:22:12.055
And, as always, let's keep fighting the good fight.

00:22:12.586 --> 00:22:17.296
And, as always, let's keep fighting the good fight.

00:22:17.296 --> 00:22:18.597
Thank you for joining us.

00:22:18.597 --> 00:22:21.904
We hope you enjoyed this theory to action podcast.

00:22:21.904 --> 00:22:32.093
Be sure to check out our show page at team mojo academycom, where we have everything we discussed in this podcast, as well as other great resources.

00:22:32.093 --> 00:22:34.999
Next time, keep getting your mojo on.

MM#364--Election 2024--Common Ground?

Listen On

Recent Episodes